Home / News / Two car dealers in hot water in South Africa

Two car dealers in hot water in South Africa

The National Consumer Tribunal has found two used car dealers in South Africa guilty of selling defective vehicles, imposing unlawful contract terms on consumers, and failing to provide redress.

The judgements, handed down between October and November 2026, reinforce compliance with the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) and were welcomed by the National Consumer Commission (NCC).

In its first ruling, the Tribunal found RC Auto Bloemfontein in contravention of section 56 read with section 55 of the CPA.

This matter involved the purchase of a 2013 VW Amarok for R249,000 on 30 June 2022 that immediately suffered severe mechanical defects, including a leaking fuel tank and failing injectors.

After suffering these problems, the consumer requested a refund and asked the dealership to collect the vehicle because she could not afford transport costs back from Richards Bay.

The dealership refused and demanded that the consumer return it to Bloemfontein at her own expense.

In its ruling, the Tribunal highlighted that suppliers are statutorily obliged to bear the risk and expense of collecting defective goods under section 56 of the CPA.

It further ordered RC Auto Bloemfontein to refund the consumer R244,000 and pay an administrative penalty of R100,000.

In a second ruling in as many months, this time against Bryanston Executive Cars, the Tribunal found the dealer guilty and liable to pay an administrative fine of R500,000 within 30 business days.

Following an investigation, the NCC revealed that the dealer sold a used 2012 Mercedes-Benz C350 for R228,935 on 10 August 2024 using false advertising.

According to the NCC, the dealer falsely advertised that the vehicle had a navigation system, misrepresented its overall condition, and included prohibited clauses in the sale agreement.

Because of several vehicle faults, the consumer was also forced to pay just over R24,000 out of pocket for major repairs, including a leaking sunroof and a faulty radiator.  

The Tribunal found the dealer to have contravened sections 29 and 41, read with section 55, and section 51 of the CPA.

While imposing administrative penalties, the Tribunal found that Bryanston Executive Cars had previously been fined in June 2024 for violating the CPA.

NCC Acting Commissioner Hardin Ratshisusu welcomed the judgments that protect consumers from unfair trade practices.

“These judgments of the Tribunal affirm the NCC’s resolve in tackling the violations of consumers’ rights, and that there are consequences for non-compliance,” he said.

“Suppliers are reminded of their obligations to protect consumer rights in terms of the CPA.”

South African used car dealers in the limelight

Last month, five car dealerships and a used car parts dealer were ordered to refund customers millions after contravening the Consumer Protection Act (CPA).

The dealerships – Flawless Cars, Sunward Motors, Used Car Centre, Auto King Milnerton, and Kia East Rand – were ordered to refund consumers millions and pay thousands in administrative fees.

In the ruling against parts dealer Spares 4 Africa, the Pretoria High Court dismissed the supplier’s appeal with costs after referring the matter to the court following the Tribunal’s original ruling.

The Tribunal initially found that the supplier contravened sections 47 and 54 of the CPA, installing the wrong engine in a consumer’s 2017 Ford Focus and retaining the vehicle for more than four years.

Flawless Cars was found to have contravened the CPA after disregarding a compliance notice issued by the NCC in August 2025.

In the Sunward Motors matter, a consumer lodged a complaint after paying R341,852.50 for a used 2016 Ford Tourneo Connect in February 2023, which then suffered multiple mechanical breakdowns.

The Tribunal also confirmed a settlement agreement between the NCC and Used Car Centre after investigations into a consumer complaint about a defective pre-owned vehicle.

In the Auto King matter, the supplier was ordered to pay R336,117.70 to a consumer and their financing bank after the Tribunal found that it had contravened the CPA.

The High Court also dismissed Kia East Rand’s appeal against the Tribunal’s ruling with costs after ruling in favour of the NCC and ordering the supplier to refund a consumer R245,075.

In all, the six automotive suppliers were ordered to pay R375,000 in fines and refund consumers R1,059,090.70, rising to R1,259,090.70 when including the prior R200,000 refund from Used Car Centre.

You have read 2 out of 5 free articles. Log in or register for unlimited access.