Home / News / Motorists are owed R14.2 million over unlawful traffic fines in South Africa

Motorists are owed R14.2 million over unlawful traffic fines in South Africa

The Road Traffic Infringement Agency (RTIA) revealed that motorists must be refunded R14.2 million for unlawfully collected traffic fines.

This was laid out in the RTIA’s annual report for the 2025/2026 financial year, where it noted that fees were collected for fines that were not correctly served under the Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Infringement (AARTO) Act.

This includes infringement fees, courtesy letters, and enforcement order fees that were collected without following the procedure laid out by South Africa’s new road laws.

“During the year ending 31 March 2026, a finding was identified that related to infringement items that were collected but have not been served in terms of the requirements of the AARTO Act,” the RTIA said.

“The RTIA then went back to determine the extent of payments that were made that should not have been paid due to the non-performance of service by our AARTO partner responsible for serving.”

The South African Post Office (SAPO) is the RTIA’s statutory partner responsible for delivering AARTO notices. This reporting period predates the Post Office’s approval to deliver notices electronically.

The RTIA noted cases where the SAPO failed to properly serve AARTO notices to motorists who had made full payments.

This applies to motorists in Tshwane and Johannesburg, where the AARTO pilot was conducted.

“Infringement fees, courtesy letters, and enforcement fees were determined to have a full value of R14,218,600,” the RTIA said.

“The RTIA will gazette the above information to invite relevant payers to then effect refunds to the infringers or allocate payments to other infringements that the individual infringer may have.”

The Post Office’s role in AARTO

The SAPO is meant to play a crucial role in the implementation of AARTO, despite the entity’s concerning track record.

It has not met its physical delivery targets mandated under its exclusive postal services licence for the last 14 years, yet it has been approved to distribute AARTO notices via electronic channels.

This has drawn criticism from civil action groups like the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (OUTA), which questioned how the SAPO could be appointed, given its performance history.

“OUTA remains concerned about the South African Post Office’s role in delivering AARTO notices,” OUTA senior legal project manager, Andrea van Heerden, told our sister publication MyBroadband.

“Given the Post Office’s longstanding financial and operational challenges, serious questions remain about its ability to reliably deliver millions of notices to motorists.”

OUTA noted that the proper delivery of AARTO notices is critical as it leads to processes and deadlines that motorists need to respond to in a timely manner.

“If notices are not delivered correctly or fail to reach their intended recipients, motorists could face penalties or other consequences without being aware that a notice has been issued against them.”

While the organisation said it supports using technology to streamline these processes, these systems are not foolproof.

There is no guarantee that a person has received an electronic notice, as email addresses and phone numbers change, meaning the SAPO’s database is likely to be incorrect.

“We must recognise that many South Africans still lack reliable Internet access or do not regularly use digital communication platforms,” Van Heerden said.

“The concern is that motorists could be expected to respond to notices they have never seen, while the AARTO process continues and further penalties or consequences accumulate.”